Welcome to The Clio Dialogues!
Nov. 18, 2026

Clio's Review of Matters of Sex

Clio's Review of Matters of Sex

Anya Jabour, Matters of Sex: Katharine Bement Davis and America's First Sexual Revolution. New York University Press, 2026.

What happens when a historian gets her hands on a collection of forgotten family papers? A remarkable woman gets her story back!

For decades, Alfred Kinsey was a household name, noted for his groundbreaking study of human sexuality. But Anya Jabour’s biography of Katharine Bement Davis turns what we thought we knew--and when we knew it--on its head. In 1929, Davis published Factors in the Sex Life of Twenty-Two Hundred Women, a study conducted through surveys. The findings challenged prevailing assumptions that respectable women were sexually passionless, decades before Kinsey's celebrated research. Not only did Davis precede Kinsey, but Jabour tells us that he drew upon her work while receiving funding from an organization that she helped establish.

Drawing on what she calls the “closet collection,” a treasure trove of correspondence, an unpublished memoir, and memorabilia discovered in a descendant's closet, Jabour reconstructs the life of a pioneering reformer. From her childhood in a fiercely feminist family, to her formative college years (earning a doctorate when few American women had such opportunities), to superintendent of Bedford Female Reformatory, and then New York City's first female commissioner of correction, she was a busy and accomplished woman. The biography also covers her personal transition from enforcer of conventional sexual morality to an advocate for women's sexual knowledge and autonomy.

While there is much to celebrate about Davis, Jabour does not overlook the sometimes uncomfortable contradictions of this Progressive Era reformer. Davis championed racial equality while also embracing eugenics. Her early commitment to women's advancement coexisted with coercive approaches to prison reform. These tensions complicate any straightforward celebration or understanding of her progressive credentials.

The biography makes an important contribution to the histories of Progressive Era reform, women's sexuality, and sexology. Accessible and thoroughly researched, Matters of Sex is a valuable addition to scholarship and teaching on U.S. history, women's history, and the history of sexuality.

Sometimes new evidence can rescue a forgotten pioneer. Jabour has notably written Davis back into history. Listen to my conversation with Anya Jabour on The Clio Dialogues history podcast, then pick up a copy of Matters of Sex and discover the remarkable woman behind the research.

 

Related Episode

17
Nov. 18, 2026

Before Kinsey: The Forgotten Pioneer of Women’s Sex Research | Anya Jabour | Matters of Sex

Historian Anya Jabour joins The Clio Dialogues history podcast host Jennifer Robin Terry to discuss Matters of Sex: Katharine Bement Davis and America's First Sexual Revolution. They talk about a remarkable collection of previously unknown letters and papers discovered in a family closet, revealing the life of a pioneering researcher whose career took her from policing women's sexuality to advocating for their sexual knowledge and autonomy. They also explore Davis's groundbreaking 1929 stu...